Asphalt Shingle Quality Roof Repair service vs Replacement - Which one works best for you?

Updated: Feb 9

Is your roof showing signs of damage? Are there shingles lying all-around your yard?

If the answer is yes, then you are not alone. Every year, hundreds of Americans collectively obsess over a single dilemma - whether to do a roof repair or a roof replacement. APD Roofing is one of the best, top-rated residential roofing companies to help you make this decision. .

The result?

Thousand of dollars spent on roof replacement that could have been a quick fix.

Most roofing companies try to push for a replacement because that is where the money is but at APD Roofing - the best and top-rated roofing company, we believe in educating the general public helping them make the most out of their budget.

So without further ado, let APD Roofing - a quality roofing services company take a look at the things you need to consider when choosing between a roof repair and a roof replacement.

Age of the roof

When it comes to your asphalt shingle roof, time is the biggest enemy. Low-end roofs on average can last up to 15 years whereas the high-end ones can go up to 40 years with regular maintenance and repairs.

So, how do you find out whether your roof is nearing its lifetime or not?

Easy. You just need to keep an eye out for a few obvious signs.

  • Curling of shingles Broken or Cracked Shingles

  • Roof valleys where a bulk of shingles go missing from your asphalt roof

  • Accumulation of moss

  • Shingle granules in the gutter

Not sure about your self-evaluation? (Check out our How to spot a roof damaged article. And of course, keep reading on here)

Don’t worry. At APD Roofing - known to be a 5 Star Rated Roofing Contractor, we can help you identify whether it's a roof repair or a roof replacement saving on unnecessary costs. Just get in touch with us and let us take care of it.

APD Roofing, the quality services company for roof repair and replacement can deal with this.

Leaks and Damages

Is your roof leaking and destroying the interiors of your lovely home?

Then maybe it’s time to get your roof replaced but before you do, you can make sure whether it is necessary or not by evaluating the severity of the damage.

Here are a few that you need to consider.

  • Leaks around your chimney

  • Leaks around your pipe boot

  • Dark strains due to leakage

  • Shingle granules accumulating on your gutter

If you have seen any of these signs, it’s time to put a new roof with quality roof repair services to prevent further damage.


When it comes to your roof, safety and security is the first concern, the next however is the budget.

A roof replacement can be 10 times more expensive and time-consuming than a simple repair.

Couple that with all the left-over debris and the noisy machines and you are looking at a construction hell.

Why lose out on the money and the peace of mind?

At APD Roofing - the best and top-rated quality roof repair service, we can help you decide whether you need a roof replacement at all. Get in touch with us and make the most out of your budget.

How long do I plan to stay there?

If you are planning to relocate to a new house soon, investing in a new roof might not be the best use of your money.

But wait, what about selling the existing one?

Studies have shown that a damaged or even an unappealing wall can drive the price of your property and gravely hurt your prospects.

At APD Roofing - the 5 stars rated roofing contractors, we give you the best of both worlds by providing a quick and affordable solution that improves the condition of your roof and retains your home’s curb appeal without burning a hole in your pocket.

Reach out to APD Roofing because only the best roofers and contractors know what’s best for you. We also offer some of the best roof materials and workmanship warranties available. That roof warranty could be important to you and you can find out more about why right here.

What do we suggest?

At APD Roofing - one of the top-rated roofing companies, we like our customers to weigh out their options and then decide what works best for them

Roof Repair is substantially cheaper than roof replacement as it can extend the life of the roof. However, it is tough to find shingles that can match the colour of your roof and a bad roofing company may cause more harm than good.

APD Roofing’s quality craftsman gives the guarantee of fine workmanship and skill gained from years of experience in the roofing industry.

On the other hand, there is replacing an old roof with a new one, which is obviously the better option if your roof is old. This replacement option will always make your home safer, more appealing, and more sellable.

However, the process could be very expensive when augmented with the cacophony of installation and multiple hidden costs in things such as gutter installation.

Most roofing companies don’t even clean up after they are done. At APD Roofing, we provide our customers with the ease of convenience by including after-work cleanup in the replacement package. It’s just one of the ways that APD Roofing provides quality roof repair & replacement services.


Getting a roof repaired or replaced is already heavy on your wallet. Why should it interfere with your mental peace too?

At APD Roofing, we take care of the entire process - from evaluation to execution and the subsequent cleanup.

So you can sit back, relax, and let us take the burden off your hands.

Get in touch with us today and save on exciting deals and discounts.

APD Roofing serves the following metro areas: Atlanta, Austin, Dallas, Fort Worth, Houston, and San Antonio. Click here to find out more.


Lead Claims Consultant, IICRC Certified